27Aug, 2025
What to Do When Your Landlord Rejects Your ESA Request

Article

Introduction

Emotional Support Animals (ESAs) are legally recognized companions that provide essential emotional and mental health support to individuals with diagnosed conditions. When moving into or renting a property, tenants may request accommodation for their ESA using a valid ESA letter from a licensed mental health professional.

Unfortunately, some landlords may reject an ESA request, either due to misunderstanding the law, fear of property damage, or skepticism about the validity of the ESA letter. Knowing your rights and the proper steps to take can prevent disputes and ensure you and your ESA can live comfortably.

”Get Yours Now!

Don’t wait until a landlord or airline tells you “no pets allowed.” Protect your rights today.

Please fill out this form and our team wil contact you ASAP.

Form Link

Complete your assessment in minutes , get approved by a licensed professional, and receive your letter within 24 hours.

Understanding ESA Rights

Under the Fair Housing Act (FHA), tenants with an ESA have the right to request reasonable accommodations:

  • Landlords cannot deny housing solely based on the presence of an ESA.
  • ESAs are not considered pets; therefore, standard pet policies, fees, or deposits usually do not apply.
  • A valid ESA letter from a licensed mental health professional must be accepted.

Exceptions for denial exist only if:

  • The ESA poses a direct threat to safety or health.
  • The ESA causes substantial property damage.
  • Providing the accommodation imposes an undue financial or administrative burden.

Refusing a legitimate ESA request without valid reasons may constitute discrimination under federal law.

Common Reasons Landlords Reject ESA Requests

  1. Misunderstanding ESA Laws
  • Many landlords confuse ESAs with regular pets and are unaware of the legal obligations.
  1. Skepticism of ESA Letters
  • Letters from online providers or unlicensed professionals may be questioned.
  1. Fear of Property Damage
  • Concerns about wear and tear, cleaning, or maintenance costs.
  1. Building or HOA Rules
  • Landlords may cite restrictive housing rules, though federal law overrides such policies when it comes to ESAs.
  1. Bias or Discrimination
  • Some landlords may hold personal biases against tenants with animals.

Steps to Take if Your ESA Request Is Rejected

  1. Verify Your ESA Letter
  • Ensure the letter is valid, on official letterhead, dated, and signed by a licensed mental health professional with their license number included.
  1. Provide Clear Documentation
  • Include your ESA’s role in alleviating mental or emotional conditions, emphasizing that the accommodation is medically necessary.
  1. Educate the Landlord
  • Explain the difference between an ESA and a pet.
  • Share legal information regarding Fair Housing Act protections.
  1. Request a Formal Review or Meeting
  • Arrange a professional discussion to clarify concerns and present your documentation.
  1. Keep Records
  • Document all communications via email or letters. Written records may be crucial if legal action becomes necessary.
  1. Seek Legal Assistance
  • Contact a tenant rights attorney or HUD if your landlord continues to refuse. HUD can investigate and enforce fair housing rights.

Tips for Preventing ESA Request Rejections

  • Use Verified ESA Letters – A letter from a licensed mental health professional is more likely to be accepted.
  • Confirm Policies Before Renting – Ask landlords about ESA accommodations upfront.
  • Maintain Professionalism – Clear, respectful communication increases the likelihood of approval.
  • Provide Additional References – Previous landlords or healthcare providers can vouch for your ESA.
  • Be Transparent About ESA Behavior – Share any training, certifications, or behavior history.

Real-Life Example

Maria, who has an ESA dog for anxiety, applied to an apartment in a no-pet building. The landlord initially rejected her ESA request, citing property rules and fear of damage.

She submitted a valid ESA letter from her licensed therapist, explained ESA rights under the Fair Housing Act, and documented all communications. After a formal meeting, the landlord approved her ESA accommodation, waived pet fees, and allowed her move-in without penalties.

This case highlights the importance of proper documentation, professional communication, and knowledge of your rights when facing a rejected ESA request.

FAQs

Q1: Can a landlord refuse my ESA request if the building is pet-free?
👉 No. Federal law requires landlords to accommodate ESAs, overriding general pet policies, except in specific exceptions.

Q2: What if my ESA letter is from an online provider?
👉 Letters from verified and licensed professionals carry more weight. Online letters may be questioned.

Q3: Can landlords charge fees for ESAs?
👉 Generally, no. ESAs are not pets, so pet fees and deposits are not applicable unless there is property damage.

Q4: Who can help if my ESA request is rejected?
👉 Contact HUD, a local fair housing agency, or a tenant rights attorney.

Q5: Can landlords ask for additional proof?
👉 Yes, they can request verification, but it must respect federal ESA laws and cannot be discriminatory.

Conclusion

Facing a landlord rejecting your ESA request can be stressful, but understanding your legal rights and proper steps can resolve most disputes. Provide valid documentation, educate your landlord, and maintain professional communication.

Your ESA is an essential companion, and federal law protects your right to housing accommodations. Taking these steps ensures a smooth rental experience while maintaining your mental and emotional well-being.

”Get Yours Now!

Don’t wait until a landlord or airline tells you “no pets allowed.” Protect your rights today.

Please fill out this form and our team wil contact you ASAP.

Form Link

Complete your assessment in minutes , get approved by a licensed professional, and receive your letter within 24 hours.